Ready to turbocharge your career? Download your free copy of the “3 Steps of Self-Mastery” Toolkit

Wooden figures on a chess board with chess pieces knocked down around them

The Trap of Confusing Aptitude and Leadership

I’m feeling riled up, and it’s Malcolm Gladwell’s fault.

That’s not easy for me to admit because I’ve had a cerebral crush on Gladwell for some time. With my AirPods tucked in my ears, I hear the pleasant lilt of his voice. I walk by doormen who think I’m smiling at them, but my smile is for Malcolm. I giggle like a schoolgirl at his witty observations like he’s whispering them in my ear at the back of the classroom while the teacher is writing on the blackboard.

Stars in His Eyes

But I wasn’t smiling or giggling as I listened to Season 5, Episode 8 of his podcast Revisionist History.

The theme of the episode focused on nihilism and the Peter Principle. Gladwell shared the research of University of Minnesota economist Alan Benson who studied the performance of sales teams using the data of 400 firms and 100,000 salespeople. The data shed light on teams’ results under two scenarios: One, when the top performing salesperson was promoted into a managerial position, and two, when someone was promoted into the role based on management’s prediction they’d be an effective leader and not based on their individual sales performance. 

When Gladwell discusses Benson’s research, he repeatedly calls the first group the “superstars.” When he references the latter, he uses precipitously demeaning language:

  • “Nice, friendly people who are good at collaborating with others”

  • “Warm and fuzzy interpersonal wusses”

  • “Incompetents”

With all due respect, Mr. Gladwell, being a salesperson and being a manager are completely different roles requiring different skillsets. It’s entirely possible that any one individual can excel at both, but as Mr. Benson’s research showed, it is more the exception than the norm for both cohorts.

Because an individual is not a superstar salesperson does not mean that they may not be a superstar leader. Leadership is not to be demeaned. It is one of the most valuable skills there is, and in the midst of a global pandemic, that is more clear than ever. Leaders unite people around a common vision, inspire them, and enable them.

Feet on the Ground

In the lecture he delivered to the plebe class at the United States Military Academy at West Point in October of 2009, William Deresiewicz explored the idea of the “superstar” versus the leader in a more nuanced and elegant way than Mr. Gladwell did in his podcast:

“Does being a leader, I wondered, just mean being accomplished, being successful? Does getting straight As make you a leader? I didn’t think so. Great heart surgeons or great novelists or great shortstops may be terrific at what they do, but that doesn’t mean they’re leaders. Leadership and aptitude, leadership and achievement, leadership and even excellence have to be different things, otherwise the concept of leadership has no meaning.”

Leadership does have meaning, and there are consequences to putting people into leadership roles that are only superstars in the arena of individual achievement. In the workplace, that creates toxic cultures, and in the world, it creates even more dire outcomes.

So I’ll get off of my soapbox and forgive Malcolm Gladwell because he’s a great writer and speaker and a deep thinker. In my opinion, he’s a superstar, and what leaders understand is even superstars have off days.

Recent Posts

Winning in the Shallow End

Winning in the Shallow End

Vince Lombardi famously said, “Winning isn’t everything; it’s the only thing.” I disagree. There are other things. Flooding Back A former colleague included me in the slate of candidates being considered to coach an employee in his organization. During the vetting...

Standing Up to the Bully in the Boardroom

Standing Up to the Bully in the Boardroom

It was 2002, not long after I’d lost my job following September 11th. It was a tough time to be out of work, so imagine my delight to get an offer about a month later. I was thrilled I wouldn’t need to spend the money from my severance package for living expenses....

What to Do When Your Client Hates You

What to Do When Your Client Hates You

The day after delivering a workshop to a corporate client, I received an email from my contact, “Let me know when you have time tomorrow to discuss yesterday’s presentation.” Twelve words. No friendly greeting. No cordial closing. I felt like I was being called to the...